Voter's Edge California Voter Guide
Conozca la información antes de votar.
Presentado por
MapLight
League of Women Voters of California Education Fund
Tuesday November 8, 2022 — California General Election
Condado

Alameda County
Measure D Ordinance - Majority Approval Required

To learn more about measures, follow the links for each tab in this section. For most screenreaders, you can hit Return or Enter to enter a tab and read the content within.

To preserve and enhance agriculture in the unincorporated area of Alameda County, shall the "Save Agriculture and Open Space Lands" Initiative (Measure D, November 2000) allow (1) a maximum floor area ratio of .025 for agricultural buildings in Large Parcel Agriculture areas and (2) a maximum floor area ratio of .025, with a minimum of 20,000 and a maximum of 60,000 square feet, for covered equestrian riding arenas in Large Parcel Agriculture and Resource Management areas?

¿Qué es esta propuesta?

Pros y Contras — Explicación objetiva con argumentos a favor y en contra

Fuente: https://acgovt-my.sharepoint.com/personal/rovonedrive_acgovt_onmicrosoft_com/Documents/Measure%20Materials/November%208,

La situación

Argument in Favor of Measure D

Twenty-two years ago, despite the vigorous opposition of developers, Alameda County voters approved Measure D, the "Save Agriculture and Open Space Lands Initiative." This measure protected Alameda County open space and agricultural areas from development and required that any changes to the ordinance had to be approved by Alameda County voters. 

The stated purpose of the measure was "to preserve and enhance agriculture and agricultural lands, and to protect the natural qualities. the wildlife habitats, the watersheds and the beautiful open spaces of Alameda County from excessive, badly located and harmful development". 

This current update of the original Measure D continues the moratorium on development in protected areas but allows for limited and essential agriculture and equestrian improvements. 

Environmental groups, business leaders, ranchers, farmers and elected officials throughout the county all support this measure.

Here is what Measure D will do:

  • Continue to prohibit uncontrolled development in areas in Alameda County designated as protected open space and agricultural areas.
  • Prohibit any structure on ridgelines or hilltops or where they will project above a ridgeline or hilltop, as viewed from public roads, trails, parks and other public viewpoints.
  • Allow ranchers and equestrian facilities to provide more space for covered corrals, practice areas for people learning to ride horses and performance areas.
  • Allow expanded storage, processing and retail facilities for wineries, olive presses etc. to serve the public. 
  • Continue to require any changes in the overall general plan for the protected areas to be approved by the voters. 

Please vote yes on Measure D

Nate Miley, Alameda County Board of Supervisors

Richard Valley, Alameda County Board of Supervisors

Lori Souza, Tri-Valley Conservancy Board Chair

Diana Hanna, Grassroots Organizer, Measure D

Dick Schneider, Co-Author Measure D

La propuesta

Rebuttal to Argument in Favor of Measure D: Open Spaces

Measure D benefits rich large landowners at our expense. Measure D ("Destroy") weakens Alameda County's environmental protections to "Allow expanded storage, processing and retail facilities for wineries."

TRIPLING in size of giant wine factories is not a "limited and essential...improvement."

New vineyards that would be illegal in Napa and Sonoma counties will destroy more Alameda County hillsides and watersheds. 

During this "severe drought" we are forced to convserve water. But local water agencies continue to supply water-guzzling Big Wineries that Measure D would grow larger. 

Measure D's backers are demanding that Alameda County spend $6,500,000.00 of your tax dollars to build Big Wineries a sewer so that they can flush this water down the drain. That money could be better used for homeless aid or child/health care, not for enabling mega-industrial wineries to squeeze extra profit from cheap wine sold at Costco. 

Low income housing is prohibited in Measure D's area. Big Winery owners Karl Wente and Darcie Kent have smeared equity activists who want to locate affordable housing elsewhere. 

Alameda County citizens have been forced to fight County-approved open space intrusions in court. They are appealing a ridiculous ruling that the 347-acre Aramis Power Plant is "agricultural" because "honeybees" and "chickens" could forage there!

When developers and the City of Livermore conspired to build on Garaventa open space/wetlands, activists successfully overturned Judge Frank Roesch's decision. Judge Roesch is the Board Chairman of a corporation that Measure D proponent/Alameda County Supervisor Richard Valley is CEO. 

Measure "Destroy" can't be trusted. Vote NO!

Author: Marcus Crawley

Sus partidarios dicen

The opponents of Measure D are well known opponents of important issues. They write ballot arguments against measures they know nothing about, including this one, to bring attention to their organization at public expense. 

In the past, they opposed protections for renters, funds for homelessness, affordable housing, childcare, and more. What is worse, over the lst two years when groups like the Sierra Club, Friends of Open Space and Vineyards, Friends of Livermore, Greenbelt Alliance, and others held countless meetings with farmers, ranchers, and elected officials to discuss how to save Alameda County open space and agriculture, they never attended a single meeting. Not one. 

The original Measure D, passed by voters over 20 years ago, requires any changes to the "Save Agriculture and Open Space Lands Initiative" to be approved by voters. These changes, approved by the original authors of Measure D and environmental groups, allow limited and essential agriculture and equestrian improvements while at the same time protecting open space. There are no factories planned, there are no corporate land barons, there is no public giveaway of funds, no authorization for construction in sensitive spaces. 

Measure D simply and effectively prohibits development in Alameda County open space. It allows ranchers to build/renovate facilities for equestrian activities. It allows greenhouses, florists, olive oil producers and vintners to expand storage and production areas- all of which must be approved individually and with strictd environmental guidelines. 

Don't be misled by those who claim facts that are not facts. Please vote Yes on Measure D. 

Nate Miley, Alameda County Board of Supervisors

Richard Valley, Alameda County Board of Supervisors

Lori Souza, Tri-Valley Conservancy Board Chair

Diana Hanna, Grassroots Organizer, Measure D

Dick Schneider, Co-Author Measure D

 

Sus oponentes dicen

Argument Against Measure D

Huge factories in scenic parts of Alameda County are BAD. Measure D would permit such destructive industrial expansion with ugly pipes and storage tanks. 

Measure D was designed to promote the corporations and land barons who control "large parcel agriculture" in our County.  They are politically powerful "one percenters." These agribusinesses are "800-pound gorillas" that want to grow [...]

Measure D would enable a handful of Big Wineries to TRIPLE in size. The Environmental Report (page 14/Table 3) admits that Alameda County's two largest wineries likely would expand by 305,000 square feet while the 41 smallest existing wineries would not grow. 

Larger wineries use more taxpayer-subsidized freshwater and produce more wastewater. This is the reason why Big Wineries want to jook up to our public sewer system and have YOU to pay their bill. The County is gifting $6,500,000 of your tax dollars to extend sewer lines several miles to Big Wineries. Small property owners right next to city limits are left out. 

Measure D is harmful to Alameda County's precious enviroment. Voters must insist on protection of "Resource Management Areas" that are "intended mainly for land designated for long-term preservation as open space" as explained in the Environmental Report (page 13). Measure D authorizes new construction in these sensitive places. 

Corporate vineyards are replacing "open space" (especially hillsides) in Alameda County. Their toxic pesticides are sprayed within a few feet of our natural waterways. Napa County and Sonoma County "Wine Country" have ordinances that restrict vineyards on hillsides and near arroyos and creeks. But Alameda County and Measure D do NOT embrace these commonsense protections. 

Measure D would worsen ecological problems. [....]

Vote NO.

Author: Marcus Crawley: Pres,, Alameda County Taxpayers' Assoc. 

 

Información básica — Información oficial

Argumentos Publicados — Argumentos a favor y en contra

Leer la legislación propuesta

Legislación propuesta

 

To preserve and enhance agriculture in the unincorporated area of Alameda County, shall the "Save Agriculture and Open Space Lands" Initiative (Measure D, November 2000) allow (1) a maximum floor area ratio of .025 for agricultural buildings in Large Parcel Agriculture areas and (2) a maximum floor area ratio of .025, with a minimum of 20,000 and a maximum of 60,000 square feet, for covered equestrian riding arenas in Large Parcel Agriculture and Resource Management areas?

Más información

Noticias (2)

Use tabs to select your choice. Use return to create a choice. You can access your list by navigating to 'My List'.

Comparta este sitio para ayudar a otras personas a investigar sus opciones para las votaciones.

PUBLISHING: SERVER:PRODUCTION