Voter's Edge California Voter Guide
Get the facts before you vote.
Brought to you by
MapLight
League of Women Voters of California Education Fund
Tuesday June 7, 2022 — California Primary Election
Invest in unbiased information

With your support, we can reach and inform more voters.

Donate now to spread the word.

Special District

Millbrae School District
Measure E - 55% Approval Required

To learn more about measures, follow the links for each tab in this section. For most screenreaders, you can hit Return or Enter to enter a tab and read the content within.

Election Results

Failing

0 votes yes (0%)

0 votes no (0%)

0 ballots counted

To improve the quality of schools by constructing classrooms/updating science, technology, engineering/math labs; rebuilding an aging elementary school; updating schools to improve student health, safety and access for students with disabilities; and updating fire, HVAC/plumbing systems, shall Millbrae Elementary School District's measure authorizing $90,000,0000 in bonds at legal rates be adopted, levying 3¢ per $100 assessed value, $6,300,000 annually, while bonds are outstanding, with citizen oversight, audits, no funds for administrators, and funds staying local?

What is this proposal?

Details — Official information

Impartial analysis / Proposal

The California Constitution and Education Code authorize a school disrtrict to issue bonds for specified purposes if approved at an election by 55% of those voting on issuance of the bonds.

The Board of Trustees of Millbrae Elementary School District ("District") proposes this Measure which would authorize the District to issue bonds in a principal amount not to exceed $90 million. The bonds will have an interest rate not exceeding the legal maximum and will be repaid within the time permitted by law. The Tax Rate Statement printed in this pamphlet contains the District's best estimates of tax rates required to service the bond debt during the life of the bonds, which is anticipated to last until June 2053. The District's best estimate of the average annual tax rate levy to fund this bond is $30 per $100,000 ($0.03/$100) of assessed valuation. The District estimates that the total amount repayable during the life of the bond, including principal and interest, will be approximately $175,358,402. 

The California Constitution requires the listing of specific projects to be funded from the bond revenue and certification that the Board of Trustees has evaluated safety, class size reduction, and information technology needs in the development of that list. The Bond Project List can be found in the full text of the Measure and includes without limitation:

* Reconfigure, replace, construct/reconstruct, or modernize sites and educational facilities;

* Construct, renovate, furnish, and equip labs and maker spaces to support STEAM instruction:

* Acquire, upgrade, and repair technology and communication infrastructure;

* Remove and replace portable classrooms with permanent classrooms;

* Construct and update classrooms for art and music;

* Create, configure, or modernize libraries, media centers, and other spaces;

* Complete health and safety improvements to comply with current student safety standards and codes;

* Upgrade access for students with disabilities and perform Americans with Disabilities Act compliance upgrades;

* Upgrade and repair electrical infrastructure;

* Upgrade utility, sewer, water, storm drain, gas lines, and plumbing infrastructure;

* Repair or replace heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems and leaky roofs;

* Install or acquire energy equipment and systems to improve energy efficiency; and

* Renovate school or classroom interiors and upgradce school or site exteriors. 

The Measure authorizes equipment acquisition, upgrades, repairs, services, construction, and other items related to the listed projects.  The Bond Project List does not imply a specific prioritization among the projects and should be reviewed for further details.

No proceeds from the bonds shall be used for teacher or administrative salaries or operating expenses.

State law requires that the District take certain steps to account for the proceeds from the bonds.  Accordingly, the District will appoint an independent citizens' oversight committee and conduct annual independent performance and financial audits to ensure that funds are spent only for the purposes listed in the Bond Project List and for no other purposes. 

A "yes" vote on this Measure would authorize the District to issue bonds in a principal amount not to exceed $90 million for the purposes listed in the Bond Project List.

A "no" vote would prevent the District from issuing the bonds.

This Measure passes if 55% of those voting on the Measure vote "yes." 

Published Arguments — Arguments for and against

Arguments FOR

Vote YES on E to repair and upgrade Millbrae schools to maintain high-quality education and prepare Millbrae graduates to excel in high school, college, and beyond.

Our schools and classrooms were built for a different era of education and need to be modernized to provide up-to-date classroom technology and meet current health and safety codes.

Voting YES on Measure E will ensure that our teachers have the tools they need to help our children succeed. Measure E helps provide all Millbrae students with equal access to modern, high-quality educational facilities.

Every penny raised by Measure E will benefit our local Millbrae schools, be controlled locally and cannot be taken by the state.

Measure E will address the most urgent and critical needs at our schools including:

*Protecting the quality of academic instruction in core subjects like math, science, reading, and writing

* Updating science, technology, engineering, and math labs at every school

* Ensuring access for students with disabilities

* Providing advanced instruction that prepares students for high school and college

* Updating technology to support our local students' learning environment for the 21st century and beyond

* Updating fire, HVAC, and plumbing systems

* Updating schools to improve student health and safety

Measure E requires strict accountability:

* All proceeds must stay in our local schools

* No funds can be taken away by the State

* An independent Citizens' Oversight Committee will be required

* No funds can be used for administrator salaries

Measure E helps our schools qualify for millions in state matching money that will otherwise go to other schools.

Even if you don't have school-age children, improving schools is a wise investment. Good schools protect our quality of life and home values.

Please join parents, teachers, seniors, elected and business leaders and vote YES on Measure E for Millbrae schools and students.

 

/s/ Frank Barbaro, President, Millbrae School District Board of Education

/s/ Lailah Morris, Attorney

/s/ Samir Thadani, MD, Cardiologist

/s/ Josephine Pasamonte Henry, President, Millbrae Educational Foundation

/s/ Steve Henderson, Teacher 

Arguments AGAINST

Millbrae Elementary School District's enrollment has declined nearly 9.4% since 2014 from 2,469 students to 2,238 in 2020-21. Yet they want to  "construct classrooms?"  For whom?

The district wants to borrow $90 million plus incur 30-40 years of interest at rates as high as 12% (legal limit).  Who has to pick up the tab? You - through increased property taxes.

These days, families are grappling with a 7.9% rise in prices so they need tax RELIEF, not the burden of another eternal "temporary" tax.

Let's do the math: $90 million divided by 2,238 students = $40,214 debt per child.

That's on top of the $12,164 they spend per child annually from property taxes.  With class size averaging 23.5, this is $285,854 per classroom per year. (Source: California Department of Education's Education Data.)

Clearly the district is not finished milking you; $90 million plus decades of interest, doubling the cost. Bond debt, just like home mortgages, must be repaid with interest.

Would your family or business take out a 30-year loan to buy a personal computer?

That would be nuts, right? But that's what this measure proposes: "Update science, technology, math, engineering labs." Just like in 2008 ($30 million) and 2011 (another $30 million) for now obsolete technology - which you and, sadly, children who were students then are still paying off!

Does either of those expense burdens make any sense whatsoever? Clearly, no!

Don't reward policies of big debt and bad spending.  Do not let them saddle you with bonded indebtedness to buy technology that goes obsolete in 4-5 years. Protect these very children from paying dearly over the next 3 or 4 decades for today's poor financial decisions by the district.

Vote NO on Measure E.

You can be FOR teachers, FOR children, and FOR education and vote AGAINST decades of bonded indebtedness.

For information, www.SVTaxpayers.org

 

/s/ Mark W.A. Hinkle, President, Silican Valley Taxpayers Association

/s/ Christopher Minoletti, Chair Pro Tem Libertarian Party of San Mateo County 

Replies to Arguments FOR

Millbrae Elementary School District's enrollment has declined nearly 9.4% since 2014 from 2,469 students to 2,238 in 2020-21. Yet they want to  "construct classrooms?"  For whom?

The district wants to borrow $90 million plus incur 30-40 years of interest at rates as high as 12% (legal limit).  Who has to pick up the tab? You - through increased property taxes.

These days, families are grappling with a 7.9% rise in prices so they need tax RELIEF, not the burden of another eternal "temporary" tax.

Let's do the math: $90 million divided by 2,238 students = $40,214 debt per child.

That's on top of the $12,164 they spend per child annually from property taxes.  With class size averaging 23.5, this is $285,854 per classroom per year. (Source: California Department of Education's Education Data.)

Clearly the district is not finished milking you; $90 million plus decades of interest, doubling the cost. Bond debt, just like home mortgages, must be repaid with interest.

Would your family or business take out a 30-year loan to buy a personal computer?

That would be nuts, right? But that's what this measure proposes: "Update science, technology, math, engineering labs." Just like in 2008 ($30 million) and 2011 (another $30 million) for now obsolete technology - which you and, sadly, children who were students then are still paying off!

Does either of those expense burdens make any sense whatsoever? Clearly, no!

Don't reward policies of big debt and bad spending.  Do not let them saddle you with bonded indebtedness to buy technology that goes obsolete in 4-5 years. Protect these very children from paying dearly over the next 3 or 4 decades for today's poor financial decisions by the district.

Vote NO on Measure E.

You can be FOR teachers, FOR children, and FOR education and vote AGAINST decades of bonded indebtedness.

For information, www.SVTaxpayers.org

 

/s/ Mark W.A. Hinkle, President, Silican Valley Taxpayers Association

/s/ Christopher Minoletti, Chair Pro Tem Libertarian Party of San Mateo County 

Replies to Arguments AGAINST

Please don't be fooled by the misleading and inaccurate information in the opposition argument. The authors reuse the same deceptive arguments and distorted data against most education ballot measures in San Mateo County.

Please consider the following facts:

Millbrae schools are up to 80 years old and in desperate need of repair. Our students should have every opportunity for success but that can't happen if our children are learning in outdated and deteriorating classrooms. The district successfully passed bond measures many years ago which provided valuable improvements but, similar to a home, repairs and renovations become necessary over time.

While enrollment has declined in most local school districts, repairs are needed for students in our schools TODAY.  Measure E will not pay for building an additional school - only repairs and renovations to existing schools.

Citizen oversight and annual independent audits will ensure transparency and accountability.  If a repair isn't on the project list, Measure E cannot fund it.

Strong schools support our community.  For many of us, the schools are the reason we moved to Millbrae.  Safe, strong schools protect Millbrae's students, community character, and property values.

Every penny of Measure E must be spent in Millbrae Elementary School District schools and cannot be taken away by the State. This is an opinion or talking point; it's a legal requirement. The project list in the voter pamphlet specifies the use of all funds.

We're voting YES on E because all current and future Millbrae students deserve safe, modern classrooms. Join us in supporting exemplary Millbrae schools.

 

/s/ Denis Fama, Trustee, Millbrae Elementary School District

/s/ Michellen Cheng, Millbrae School District Parent

/s/ Ramtin Aidi, Teacher

/s/ Bill Meyer, Human Resources Consultant

/s/ Vivian Chu, Assisant Vice-President, Financial Crimes, Wells Fargo 

Use tabs to select your choice. Use return to create a choice. You can access your choices by navigating to 'My Choices'.

Please share this site to help others research their voting choices.

PUBLISHING: SERVER:PRODUCTION